A LUTHERAN POSITION ON BAPTISM
From Original Sources
In order to avoid any misrepresentation, the following
statements are all taken from Lutheran sources.
“The first thing in baptism to be considered is the
divine promise, which says: ‘He that believes and is baptized shall be saved’…
The second part of baptism is the sign, or sacrament, which is that immersion
into water from this also it derives its name. For the
Greek baptizo means ‘I immerse,’ and baptisma means ‘immersion.’” (From “The Babylonian Captivity of the Church” by
Martin Luther, 1520.)
“The act or rite [of baptism] consists in being placed
into the water, which flows over us, and being drawn from it again. These two
things, the placing in the water and emerging from it signify the power and
efficacy of baptism; which is simply the mortifying of the old Adam in us and
the resurrection of the new man, both of which operations continue in us as
long as we live on the earth.” (Martin Luther, Large Catechism, 1529, Dr. J. N.
Lenker’s translation, pages 168-169.)
NOTE: The following statements are taken from the 1521
edition of the book, “LOCI COMMUNES” [i.e. Common Topics] by Philip Melanchthon [Charles leander
Hill’s translation]. Luther had only the highest praise for that book. However,
it is sometimes wrongly confused with a book by the same name that Melanchthon
published two decades later – which contained certain controversial and
divisive statements.
“I have said that the
gospel is the promise of grace. Moreover next to promises is the place of
signs. For in the Scripture signs are added to the promises for a mark. These
signs remind us of the promises and are sure testimonies of the divine will
toward us. They also bear witness that of a certainty we will receive what God
has promised unto us. Gross errors are made in the use of signs. For when the
schools dispute about the difference between the sacraments of the Old and the
New Testaments they deny that the sacraments of the Old Testament had any power
to justify. They attribute to the New Testament sacraments (though by a
manifest error) the power to justify. For faith alone justifies.” [Pages
238-239.]
“Moreover, what is the nature of signs can be most
easily understood from Paul’s epistle to the Romans. In the fourth chapter the
following discussion of circumcision is contained. According to Paul, Abraham
was not, justified by circumcision, but before it and without its merit. He did
however later receive circumcision as a sign, by which God would witness that
Abraham was just, and by which Abraham himself would
be conscious of the fact that he was just in the sight of God, lest fluctuating
in a doubtful conscience he might give himself over to despair. If you
understand this function, what can come about more joyfully than signs? It is
not enough for signs to remind one of the promises; it is a matter’ of great
importance though that ‘they are a sure testimony of the divine will toward us.”
[Page 239.]
“Thus Moses (Gen. 14:11) calls circumcision a sign:
‘That it may be unto you for a sign of the covenant between me and you.’
Because circumcision is a sign it reminds Abraham of the divine promise, and
not, only him alone but all who were circumcised. Because circumcision is a
sign of the covenant, that is, because it signifies that the covenant will be
ratified, it confirms the conscience of Abraham. Hence it results that he
doubts nothing but that it will come to pass just what has been promised.
Doubting nothing, I say, but that God will fulfill just what he has promised.
But what did God promise to Abraham? Was it not that he would be a God to
Abraham, that is, did he not promise to embrace Abraham, to save and justify
him? So Abraham doubted not but that these things were sure, having been
confirmed by circumcision as it were a mark.” [Pages
239-240.]
“Run through the whole of Scripture if you will and
seek out the nature of signs from the sacred histories, but not from the impious
Sophists. The Lord extends Hezekiah’s life because of Isaiah’s prayer. Now that
the king may know for a certainty that this promise will be kept, God confirms
it by the addition of a sign: the shadow of the horologe should be turned back
ten degrees (II Kings 20). Lest Gideon should doubt that
“Signs do not justify, as Paul says in I Corinthians
7:19: ‘Circumcision is nothing,’ and so baptism and participation in the Lord’s table are nothing but witnesses of the divine will
toward you. And your conscience, if at all in doubt, is rendered certain by
them of the grace and benevolence of God toward it. As Hezekiah could not doubt
the fact that he would recover when he had both heard the promise and had seen.
it confirmed by a sign; as Gideon could not doubt the fact that he would be a
victor, when he was confirmed by so many signs; just so, ought you not doubt
the fact that you have attained mercy, when you have heard the gospel preached
and received its baptism, and the body and blood of the Lord. But if you will,
Hezekiah could have been restored to his health even without a sign had he been
willing only to believe the bare promise. Likewise Gideon would have been
victorious without a sign, if he had believed. So you can be justified without
a sign provided you believe.” [Pages 240-241.]
“Indeed signs do not justify, but the faith of
Hezekiah and that of Gideon likewise had to be supported, strengthened, and confirmed
by such signs. In such manner is our weakness strengthened by signs lest amid
so many insults of sin, it may despair of God’s mercy. Just as you would
consider it a sign of divine favor were God to talk face to face with you, or
show you some peculiar pledge of mercy such as a miracle, so in like manner it
behooves you to perceive concerning these signs that you believe that God has
commiserated you when you receive baptism or participate in the Lord’s table
just as certainly as you would seem to believe, if God talked face to face with
you or showed you some other miracle that pertains particularly to yourself.
For signs were instituted for the purpose of — exciting faith. Now however,
both faith and the use of signs have been extinguished, by those who extract
gain, from them. The knowledge of signs is most salubrious, and I by no means
know anything else that so consoles the conscience and more efficaciously
confirms it than the use of signs.” [Page 241.]
“Some call them sacraments; but I call them signs, or if
you so will, sacramental signs. For Paul calls Christ himself a sacrament. (
“In
the gospel moreover, Christ has instituted two signs, to wit, baptism and the
Table of the Lord. For I judge sacramental signs to be those that have been
divinely given as tokens of God’s grace. For we men
cannot institute a sign of the divine will toward us, nor refer those signs as
signifying the divine will, which Scripture has referred to another. I wonder
the more, what has entered the minds of the Sophists, especially since they
would attribute our justification to signs, to cause them to reckon among signs
those things of which the Scripture does not mention even one word. For whence
has the priestly order been invented? And too, God never instituted marriage to
be a proper sign of grace. The rite of unction is older than the sign of grace.
Luther has copiously treated this matter in his ‘Babylonian Captivity.’ From it
you may seek a more exact discussion of this subject. But this is the sum of
the matter: grace is not signified with certainty and indeed properly, except
by those signs which have been divinely transmitted. Thus only those which have
been added to the divine promises can be rightly called sacramental signs. The
ancients were accustomed to say here that sacraments consist of things and
words. The thing is the sign, the words the promise of grace.” [Pages 242-243.]
[The quotes from, “Loci Communes” end here.]
NOTE: The following quotations are from the Tappert edition of the, “BOOK OF CONCORD,” or from Lenker’s translation of the “LARGE CATECHISM”.
“Paul teaches that we are justified not by the law but
by the promise, which is received by faith only. … Therefore we must first take
hold of the promise by faith, that for Christ’s sake the Father is reconciled
and forgiving.” (Book of
“If we define the sacraments as
rites ‘which have the command of God and to which the promise of grace has been
added.’ (Melanchthon’s
definition, from Loci 1521) … When we are baptized, when we
eat the Lord’s body, when we are absolved, our hearts should firmly believe
that God really forgives us for Christ’s sake.” (Book of
“The Word and the rite have the same effect, as
Augustine said so well when he called the sacrament ‘the visible Word,’ for the
rite is received by the eyes and is sort of a picture of the Word, signifying
the same thing as the Word.” (Book of
“It is sheer Judaism to believe that we are justified
by a ceremony without a good disposition in our heart, that is, without faith
[in Christ]. … A promise is useless unless faith accepts it. The sacraments are
signs of the promises. When they are used, therefore, there must be faith.”
(Book of
“Here we are talking about personal faith, which
accepts the promise as a present reality and believes that the forgiveness of
sins is actually being offered, not about a faith which believes in a general
way that God exists. … Words cannot describe the abuses which this fanatical
notion, about the sacraments ex opere operato without a good disposition in the one using them,
has spawned in the church. (Book of
“Faith [in Christ] alone makes one worthy to
profitably receive this saving, divine water” // Without
faith baptism avails nothing” (Large Catechism, Tappert,
page 440, Lenker, page 129)
“The sacraments are not only signs among men,
but signs of God’s will toward us; so it is correct to define the New Testament
sacraments as signs of grace. There are two parts to a sacrament, the sign and
the Word. In the New Testament, the Word is the added promise of grace. The
promise of the New Testament is the promise of the forgiveness of sins, as the
text says, ‘this is my body, which is given for you’; ‘this is the cup of the new testament with my blood, which is poured out for many
for the forgiveness of sins.’ (Luke 22:19, Matt. 26:28) Therefore the Word
offers forgiveness of sins, while the ceremony is a sort of picture or ‘seal,’
as Paul calls it (Rom.
Adult Baptism
Scripture expressly points out that only such adults are to
be baptized as have previously come to faith in Christ. Of those baptized on
the First Pentecost we read: “Then they that gladly received his word were
baptized” (Acts
With
respect to adults, Scripture expressly points out that only such should be
baptized as believe in, and confess, Christ, Acts 2:4, 8:36-38.
["CHRISTIAN DOGMATICS", by John Theodore Mueller, page 497.]
Infant Baptism
Although Martin Luther was convinced that infant
baptism had come from the Apostles, he “freely
admitted that infant baptism is neither explicitly commanded
or explicitly mentioned in Scripture”. (“The Theology of Martin
Luther,” by Paul Althaus, page 361)
“In making an argument for infant faith Luther proceeds cautiously. He conceded
that Scripture does not prove this unequivocally; there are no passages which
explicitly state: ‘You are to baptize children because they also believe.’ But
his method in general is to cast the burden of proof on the Anabaptists. He
asks: Since the Bible nowhere denies infant faith how can they be sure children
cannot believe? Then he proceeds to cite texts suggestive of infant faith such
as Herod’s murder of the holy innocents (how could they be innocent if they did
not believe in Christ?) in Matthew 2 and John the Baptist’s leaping in the womb
at the greeting of Mary (Luke
“Luther once remarked that he, too, would omit infant
baptism if he felt constrained to hold that children could not themselves
believe” (St. L. XI:490). Nevertheless, he did not believe that lack of faith
made baptism invalid but instead held that, “When faith comes, baptism is
complete”. (‘LUTHERAN QU
Faith in Christ is Indispensable
“The Word of God is not rightly divided when men are
taught that the Sacraments produce salutary effects ex opere
operato, that is, by the mere outward performance of
a sacramental act.
“The grave error which is scored by this thesis is
held by the papists, who teach men that they will derive some benefit by merely
submitting to the act of being baptized, despite the fact that they are still
unbelievers, provided they are not actually living in mortal sins… The truth is
that Baptism and Holy Communion place any person under condemnation who does
not approach them with faith in his heart. They are means of grace only for the
reason that a divine promise has been attached to an external symbol…. It is of
paramount importance that I believe, that I regard, not the water in Baptism,
but the promise which Christ has attached to the water. It is this promise [of
forgiveness in Christ] that requires the water… Grace does not operate in a
chemical or in a mechanical manner, but only by the Word, by virtue of God’s
saying continually: “Thy sins are forgiven thee.” To this word I must cling by
faith. If I do that, I can confidently meet God on the Last Day.” (LAW AND
GOSPEL, by C.F.W. Walther, pages 345-347.)
Conclusion
Rightly understood, Lutheran teaching holds that Baptism
is a visible sign to which God has attached His promise of forgiveness in
Christ. Just as the faith of Abraham, “was accounted to him for righteousness,”
when he believed God’s promise of forgiveness in Christ, so likewise our faith
is accounted to us as righteousness when we believe God’s promise of forgiveness
in Christ (Galatians 3:6, Romans 3:28). Baptism is just one way in which God
gives us that promise.
“Properly speaking, there is but one means of grace,
namely, the Gospel of Christ (Rom.
Gary Ray Branscome